Low regulatory T-cells: A distinct immunological subgroup in minimal change nephrotic syndrome with early relapse following rituximab therapy

Abstract

Rituximab is an important second line therapy in difficult nephrotic syndrome (NS), especially given toxicity of long-term glucocorticoid or calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) use. However, clinical response to rituximab is heterogenous. We hypothesized that this was underpinned by immunological differences amongst patients with NS. We recruited a cohort of 18 subjects with glucocorticoid-dependent or glucocorticoid-resistant childhood-onset minimal change NS who received rituximab either due to CNI nephrotoxicity, or due to persistent glucocorticoid toxicity with inadequate response to cyclophosphamide or CNIs. Immunological subsets, T-cell activation assays and plasma cytokines were measured at baseline and 6-months post-rituximab. Time to relapse was bifurcated: 56% relapsed within one year ("early relapse"), while the other 44% entered remission mainly lasting >/=3 years ("sustained remission"). At baseline, early relapse compared to sustained remission group had lower regulatory T-cells (Tregs) [2.94 (2.25, 3.33)% vs 6.48 (5.08, 7.24)%, P<0.001], PMA-stimulated IL-2 [0.03 (0, 1.85)% vs 4.78 (0.90, 9.18)%, P=0.014] and IFNgamma [2.22 (0.18, 6.89)% vs 9.47 (2.72, 17.0)%, P=0.035] levels. Lower baseline Treg strongly predicted early relapse (ROC-AUC 0.99, 95% CI 0.97-1.00, P<0.001). There were no differences in baseline plasma cytokine levels. Following rituximab, there was significant downregulation of Th2 cytokines in sustained remission group (P=0.038). In particular, IL-13 showed a significant decrease in sustained remission group [-0.56 (-0.64, -0.35)pg/ml, P=0.007)], but not in the early relapse group. In conclusion, early relapse following rituximab is associated with baseline reductions in Treg and T-cell hyporesponsiveness, which suggest chronic T-cell activation and may be useful predictive biomarkers. Sustained remission, on the other hand, is associated with downregulation of Th2 cytokines following rituximab.